One Body, Many Parts
Individualism, Collectivism, & Faith
Street evangelism used to be one of my favorite things to do with some brothers in the faith during the week after work on Wednesdays or Thursdays. We had conversations with many different types of people from many different backgrounds. And let me tell you… the moments and stories were never dull. Some were sad. Some were entertaining. And some were downright absurd. But all of the stories - and the people who were shaped by them - needed the love and redemption of Jesus.
On occasion I would have conversations with someone who was into some form of African spirituality or another heterodox, pro-black spiritual belief. I was always interested to talk to these individuals because as I grew deeper in my relationship with Christ and started paying attention to more of what was going on in the world and in the church, the more I started to understand how and why they came to their conclusions about their blackness and the spiritual beliefs that had adopted.
“The Black Diaspora has been through centuries of struggle, resistance, and joy since being scattered from our original homelands. And through it all, many of us have connected with those original practices — food, family structures, languages — as a way of healing and building community with each other. The same goes for African and Black Diasporic spirituality, like the Yoruba, Lucumí, and Santería traditions; many practitioners of these religions offer a different type of healing, one that is removed from traditionally Westernized versions, which generally stress individualism and independence. African traditions, instead, are reliant upon collectivism, strong communities, and healthy interdependence.”
“How Some Black Americans Are Finding Solace in African Spirituality” (https://www.vox.com/2020/7/31/21346686/orisha-yoruba-african-spirituality-covid)
Sociology & The Body of Christ
8 months and 2 semesters after I came to know Jesus at Georgia State University, I took a sociology class that was on track with my major. I can’t remember the exact name of it, but my teacher was Korean and I learned about individualist and collectivist societies. Can you guess which one we live in?
In Western societies like the United States, we are considered individualist. “Individualists promote realizing one's goals and desires, valuing independence and self-reliance, and advocating that the interests of the individual should gain precedence over the state or a social group, while opposing external interference upon one's own interests by society or institutions such as the government individualism.” Another definition says, “Some believe that individualism boosts self-confidence, promotes individual excellence and enhances creativity, but it may also lead to resistance to change, lack of cooperation and increased conflicts.“ In an individualist society, community is not completely null and void, but it is not valued as much as it is in collectivist societies.
Eastern societies are more collectivist and “focus on the group’s needs by working together as opposed to focusing on individual needs.” “Common interest rather than personal interest is highly valued and there is a greater incentive to foster stronger relationship between peers.” Collectivism focuses on taking care of people in the whole society, especially those that need help. Though the individual matters, community and the “common good” is more heavily emphasized as is honor and duty to family, community, and society as a whole.
Hyper-individualism does not acknowledge themselves as being part of a group. They believe in ONLY looking out for one’s self without considering others and how they might be affected by themselves and their actions.
Hyper-collectivism does not acknowledge individual choices and autonomy at all. The individual will sacrifice unnecessarily for the good of the group. This shows up in countries like North Korea with the concept of “collective punishment” where if one person commits a heinous crime, they will be imprisoned along with their families. If it’s really bad, 3 generations of their family will be born in and die in prison as a consequence of their individual actions.
A sinful, unsubmitted heart + individualism or collectivism = destruction of self and others.
Which One Is Best?
It was in that sociology class that the Scriptures where Jesus talks about the body being one, yet having many parts and different functions really came to life for me.
I don’t know about you, but as we discussed the ins and outs of each social theory, I asked myself, “Do either of these theories really fit what God has said in His Word? Are we, as devout followers of Jesus, to focus more on the individual or the community?”
“YES."